| All-time record | Played 2131, Won 832, Drawn 415, Lost 884 |
|---|
| Record win in all competitions | Carlton Town 6–0 Sancti Spiritus — 2002/03 FA Cup Second Round, Carlton Town 6–0 Chapeltown Academical — 2009/10 Beta League, Carlton Town 7–1 Princes Yeomouth — 2010/11 Beta League, Carlton Town 6–0 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2016/17 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record home win in all competitions | Carlton Town 6–0 Sancti Spiritus — 2002/03 FA Cup Second Round, Carlton Town 6–0 Chapeltown Academical — 2009/10 Beta League, Carlton Town 7–1 Princes Yeomouth — 2010/11 Beta League, Carlton Town 6–0 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2016/17 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record away win in all competitions | Wyvernmouth Dockers 0–5 Carlton Town — 1977/78 Islands League, West Walpool Juniors 0–5 Carlton Town — 1996/97 FA Cup Second Round Replay, Vaughanstown 0–5 Carlton Town — 2010/11 Beta League, Little Antonito 0–5 Carlton Town — 2021/22 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record win in the league | Carlton Town 6–0 Chapeltown Academical — 2009/10 Beta League, Carlton Town 7–1 Princes Yeomouth — 2010/11 Beta League, Carlton Town 6–0 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2016/17 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record home win in the league | Carlton Town 6–0 Chapeltown Academical — 2009/10 Beta League, Carlton Town 7–1 Princes Yeomouth — 2010/11 Beta League, Carlton Town 6–0 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2016/17 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record away win in the league | Wyvernmouth Dockers 0–5 Carlton Town — 1977/78 Islands League, Vaughanstown 0–5 Carlton Town — 2010/11 Beta League, Little Antonito 0–5 Carlton Town — 2021/22 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record loss in all competitions | FC Brados 10–1 Carlton Town — 2020/21 Brados Cup First Round |
|---|
| Record home loss in all competitions | Carlton Town 0–6 New Plymouth Mariners — 2012/13 FA Cup Second Round |
|---|
| Record away loss in all competitions | FC Brados 10–1 Carlton Town — 2020/21 Brados Cup First Round |
|---|
| Record loss in the league | La Robla 8–1 Carlton Town — 2011/12 Beta League |
|---|
| Record home loss in the league | Carlton Town 0–5 Purditon Town — 1979/80 Islands League, Carlton Town 2–7 Whitburn Carew — 1981/82 Islands League, Carlton Town 0–5 Purditon Town — 1982/83 Islands League, Carlton Town 0–5 Courton Lees — 1992/93 Beta League |
|---|
| Record away loss in the league | La Robla 8–1 Carlton Town — 2011/12 Beta League |
|---|
| Highest scoring game | FC Brados 10–1 Carlton Town — 2020/21 Brados Cup First Round |
|---|
| Most consecutive league wins | 9 — 2013/14 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league draws | 7 — 1983/84 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league defeats | 14 — 2001/02 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league games without defeat | 21 — 2023/24–2024/25 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league games without victory | 19 — 2015/16 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league wins | 12 — 2016/17–2017/18 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league defeats | 10 — 2005/06 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league wins | 5 — 2017/18 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league defeats | 19 — 2004/05–2005/06 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league games without defeat | 25 — 2016/17–2017/18 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league games without victory | 17 — 2014/15–2015/16 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league games without defeat | 12 — 2023/24–2024/25 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league games without victory | 19 — 2004/05–2005/06 |
|---|
