| All-time record | Played 2031, Won 695, Drawn 380, Lost 956 |
|---|
| Record win in all competitions | Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Sancti Spiritus — 1974/75 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Santiago de Brados — 1980/81 Islands First Division, Kintyre Coastguard 0–6 Baptist Railway Athletic — 1983/84 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Wincanton Athletic — 2010/11 Islands First Division, Little Padstow 0–6 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2019/20 FA Cup First Round |
|---|
| Record home win in all competitions | Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Sancti Spiritus — 1974/75 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Santiago de Brados — 1980/81 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Wincanton Athletic — 2010/11 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record away win in all competitions | Kintyre Coastguard 0–6 Baptist Railway Athletic — 1983/84 Islands First Division, Little Padstow 0–6 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2019/20 FA Cup First Round |
|---|
| Record win in the league | Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Sancti Spiritus — 1974/75 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Santiago de Brados — 1980/81 Islands First Division, Kintyre Coastguard 0–6 Baptist Railway Athletic — 1983/84 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Wincanton Athletic — 2010/11 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record home win in the league | Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Sancti Spiritus — 1974/75 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Santiago de Brados — 1980/81 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 6–0 Wincanton Athletic — 2010/11 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record away win in the league | Kintyre Coastguard 0–6 Baptist Railway Athletic — 1983/84 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record loss in all competitions | St Vincent All Stars 9–1 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2008/09 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record home loss in all competitions | Baptist Railway Athletic 0–6 East Camberwell United — 1986/87 Brados Cup First Round, Baptist Railway Athletic 0–6 Worthington Rovers — 1994/95 Islands First Division, Baptist Railway Athletic 0–6 West Heath Rangers — 2025/26 Brados Cup First Round |
|---|
| Record away loss in all competitions | St Vincent All Stars 9–1 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2008/09 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record loss in the league | St Vincent All Stars 9–1 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2008/09 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record home loss in the league | Baptist Railway Athletic 0–6 Worthington Rovers — 1994/95 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Record away loss in the league | St Vincent All Stars 9–1 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2008/09 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Highest scoring game | St Vincent All Stars 9–1 Baptist Railway Athletic — 2008/09 Islands First Division |
|---|
| Most consecutive league wins | 6 — 2000/01, 2001/02, 2004/05, 2010/11, 2017/18–2018/19, 2020/21 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league draws | 4 — 1999/00, 2008/09 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league defeats | 18 — 1994/95 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league games without defeat | 19 — 2019/20–2020/21 |
|---|
| Most consecutive league games without victory | 33 — 1993/94–1994/95 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league wins | 9 — 1986/87 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league defeats | 12 — 1994/95 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league wins | 6 — 2024/25–2025/26 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league defeats | 11 — 2024/25 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league games without defeat | 17 — 2020/21–2021/22 |
|---|
| Most consecutive home league games without victory | 16 — 1993/94–1994/95 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league games without defeat | 10 — 1999/00, 2002/03 |
|---|
| Most consecutive away league games without victory | 20 — 1993/94–1994/95 |
|---|
